Shattering the Silence: Confronting Men’s Mental Health Challenges in South Africa
#42
South Africa’s men and boys are grappling with a silent mental health crisis, one fueled by deeply ingrained cultural norms that equate masculinity with stoicism and emotional suppression. The expectation to “man up” and hide vulnerability drives alarming rates of suicide, substance abuse, and gender-based violence (GBV), leaving countless lives in turmoil. While Men’s Mental Health Month in June sparks vital conversations, this issue demands year-round attention to dismantle stigma and expand access to support. Drawing on personal stories, expert insights from Jaco van Schalkwyk of The Character Company, and critical data from sources like the South African Depression and Anxiety Group (SADAG) and a recent IOL article, this blog explores the multifaceted mental health challenges facing South African men, the systemic barriers they encounter, and actionable resources for healing.
Unmasking the Crisis: The State of Men’s Mental Health
South Africa faces a profound mental health crisis, particularly among men. In 2019, of the 13,774 mental health-related deaths recorded, 79% (10,861) were men, with suicide ranking as a leading cause of death. Men are four to five times more likely to die by suicide than women, often using more lethal methods, according to SADAG. This disparity stems from cultural norms that discourage emotional expression, branding vulnerability as weakness. Jaco van Schalkwyk, CEO of The Character Company, which mentors fatherless boys, notes, “There’s a chronic lack of emotional well-being among the country’s boys and men.” These norms push men toward destructive coping mechanisms, such as alcohol, drugs, or violence, exacerbating personal and societal harm, including South Africa’s GBV epidemic, with over 40,000 domestic violence cases reported annually.
Economic pressures amplify this crisis. With an unemployment rate of 33% (Statistics South Africa, 2024), many men struggle to fulfill the traditional role of provider, leading to feelings of inadequacy and shame. Adverse childhood experiences, such as growing up in fatherless homes, a reality for over 60% of South African children, further increase the risk of mental health issues, including depression and anxiety. Systemic barriers, like limited access to mental health services (only 5% of the national health budget) and a shortage of professionals (1.4 mental health workers per 100,000 people), leave men with few options for support. In this context, the stigma around seeking help becomes a life-and-death issue, demanding urgent action.
Voices of Struggle: Stories That Humanize the Crisis
Personal narratives reveal the devastating impact of societal expectations and systemic challenges on South African men’s mental health.
Thabo’s Burden: The Pressure to Provide
Thabo, a 29-year-old from Soweto, lost his factory job during an economic downturn, plunging him into despair. In South Africa, where cultural norms tie a man’s worth to his role as provider, Thabo’s unemployment felt like a personal failure. “I was taught a man who can’t provide isn’t a man,” he shared. To cope, he turned to alcohol, a common escape for 31% of South African men who engage in binge drinking, according to the South African Medical Research Council. This deepened his depression and strained his family relationships, reflecting a broader pattern where economic hardship and masculinity norms drive men into a cycle of shame and substance abuse.
Sipho’s Stagnation: Trapped by Systemic Barriers
Sipho, a 24 year old from rural Mpumalanga, faced a different struggle. Limited to low-paying labor jobs due to a lack of formal education, he felt trapped with no path forward. A study in the Ehlanzeni district found that 62% of young men cite fear of stigma and societal expectations as barriers to discussing mental health with family or friends. Sipho’s sense of worthlessness grew, fueling anxiety and hopelessness. With mental health services scarce in rural areas, where outpatient visits are only 14 per 100,000 compared to a global average of 1,051, Sipho’s story highlights how systemic inequities, like poverty and limited access to education, exacerbate mental health challenges.
My Journey: Embracing Vulnerability
I’ve faced my mental health battles, and sharing them is both daunting and essential. Growing up in South Africa, I absorbed the message that men must be unbreakable. Traumas from childhood losses and navigating a society steeped in violence left scars that resurface unpredictably. On tough days, my mind feels like a storm, with anxiety and unresolved emotions clouding even simple tasks. For years, I tried to suppress the pain, believing strength meant silence.
Mindfulness practices, such as meditation and journaling, help me process thoughts, while honest conversations with friends and family have been a lifeline. Healing is not linear. I’m still on this path, but I’ve learned that vulnerability is a strength, not a weakness. In a society that shames men for speaking out, taking that first step to seek help is an act of courage. My story is a call to others: if I can do this, so can you.
The GBV Connection: A Societal Ripple Effect
Unaddressed mental health issues among men contribute to South Africa’s GBV crisis. The Character Company’s work with fatherless boys shows that unprocessed trauma often manifests as anger or violence, perpetuating cycles of harm. Programs like these aim to teach emotional literacy, but the scale of the problem, compounded by high crime rates and socio-economic instability, demands broader intervention. These stories highlight the importance of safe spaces where men can openly express their emotions without fear of judgment.
Resources for Healing: Where to Turn
To every man and boy in South Africa: your pain is valid, and you are not alone. Seeking help is a sign of strength. Despite South Africa’s underfunded mental health system, several organizations offer free or low-cost support tailored to local communities. Here are key resources:
South African Depression and Anxiety Group (SADAG): Provides free phone-based counseling from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., 7 days a week. Call the Mental Health Line at (011) 234 4837 or Suicide Crisis Helpline at (0800) 12 13 14. SADAG also offers referrals to local support groups.
LifeLine South Africa: Offers 24/7 crisis intervention with free, confidential counseling at (0861) 322 322 for trauma, relationships, or emotional distress.
The Counselling Hub: Run by the SACAP Foundation in Cape Town, provides low-cost counseling for anxiety, depression, stress, and relationships.
Hope House: Operates in three Cape Town locations, offering counseling for trauma, addiction, and grief for children, teens, and adults.
Family and Marriage Society of South Africa (FAMSA): Specializes in relationship counseling, addressing marital conflict and GBV, with nationwide services.
Humanitas Training & Counselling: Provides free online counseling by psychology and social work interns via www.humanitas.co.za, ideal for discreet support in rural areas.
HEAL SA Helpline: Offers free, confidential counseling via phone (010 880 3334) or WhatsApp (066 323 6869 or 081 516 5178), designed for underserved communities.
For immediate crisis support, contact SADAG’s Suicide Crisis Helpline at (0800) 12 13 14 or the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 988. If you’re supporting a man in your life, listen without judgment, encourage open dialogue, and share these resources. A simple “I’m here for you” can change everything.
A Roadmap to Change: Confronting Stigma and Barriers
Addressing men’s mental health in South Africa requires a multi-pronged approach to tackle cultural, systemic, and community-level challenges.
Rewriting Masculinity
Cultural norms that equate emotional expression with weakness must be challenged. Initiatives like The Character Company’s mentorship programs teach boys emotional literacy, helping them process feelings without resorting to destructive behaviors. Schools, workplaces, and community centers can host mental health dialogues, as seen in UNICEF’s Eastern Cape program, which trained 39 facilitators across 24 schools to support youth.
Systemic Reform
South Africa’s mental health infrastructure is critically underfunded, with only 1.4 mental health workers per 100,000 people compared to a global average of 9.0. Policymakers must increase funding to expand services, especially in rural areas where access is limited. Digital solutions, like mobile health apps, show promise, 98.7% of university students own smartphones, but apps must be culturally tailored to address stigma and linguistic diversity. Telemedicine, successful in the private sector during COVID-19, could scale up public mental health access if prioritized.
Community Engagement
Communities are key to breaking the silence. Families and friends can create safe spaces by checking in with men and boys, asking, “How are you doing?” Grassroots efforts, like SADAG’s support groups or the Mthatha Express Men’s Conference (June 2025), foster open dialogue. Employers can offer mental health days and Employee Assistance Programs, normalizing self-care. Public health campaigns, like UNICEF’s 2023 Facebook campaign reaching 17.5 million South Africans, prove the power of awareness in reducing stigma.
Addressing GBV
The link between men’s mental health and GBV requires targeted intervention. Unprocessed trauma often fuels violence, perpetuating South Africa’s GBV crisis. Programs like FAMSA’s relationship counseling and The Character Company’s mentorship can teach men to manage emotions constructively, reducing harm to themselves and others.
A Collective Call to Action
South Africa’s men and boys deserve a future where mental health is prioritized and vulnerability is embraced. The crisis, marked by 79% of mental health deaths being male, a suicide rate four to five times higher than women, and systemic barriers like underfunding, demands urgent action. We must challenge the “men don’t cry” mentality, expand access to services, and create safe spaces for honest conversations. Check in with the men in your life, ask, listen, and share resources like SADAG or Lifeline. Advocate for policy changes to boost mental health funding. Support organizations that mentor boys and men to break cycles of trauma.
Together, we can build a South Africa where no man or boy suffers in silence. Take that first step today, reach out, start a conversation, or call a helpline.
Healing is possible, and it begins with shattering the silence.
In case You Missed It
Youth Month 2025: Leadership – Shaping Tomorrow
As South Africa celebrates Youth Month in June 2025, we reflect on the fearless spirit of the 1976 Soweto and Sharpeville uprisings, where young people stood against apartheid’s injustices, igniting a movement for freedom. Today, that same courage and vision shine through a new generation of leaders, all under 36, who are shaping South Africa’s future w…
If you’re enjoying the newsletter, please share it with a friend or on social media. Your support means the world!